Valgus stress test

The valgus stress test is a clinical maneuver used to assess the integrity of the medial collateral ligament of the knee. It is widely employed in orthopedic and sports medicine practice to evaluate medial joint stability after injury.

By applying a controlled valgus force to the knee, clinicians can determine the degree of medial ligament laxity, identify partial or complete tears, and guide treatment and rehabilitation strategies.

Introduction

The valgus stress test evaluates the stability of the medial structures of the knee, particularly the medial collateral ligament. This test helps detect ligamentous injuries that can result from trauma, sports participation, or chronic instability. Accurate performance and interpretation of the test are essential for diagnosis, management, and surgical planning.

It is a simple, noninvasive procedure that provides immediate clinical information about medial joint integrity. The results are interpreted in conjunction with the patient’s history, physical examination findings, and, when necessary, imaging studies such as MRI or ultrasound.

Anatomy Relevant to the Valgus Stress Test

Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL)

• Superficial fibers: Extend from the medial femoral epicondyle to the medial tibial condyle, providing primary resistance to valgus stress.
• Deep fibers: Attach to the medial meniscus and joint capsule, contributing to medial stability and limiting rotational stress.
• Blood supply: Derived from branches of the medial genicular arteries.
• Innervation: Branches from the obturator and femoral nerves, providing proprioceptive feedback.

Adjacent Structures

• Medial meniscus: Reinforces medial stability and is susceptible to injury when the MCL is damaged.
• Joint capsule: Thickened medially to support ligamentous structures and prevent excessive valgus motion.
• Pes anserinus and surrounding musculature: Provide dynamic stabilization to the medial knee and influence test results if tight or injured.

Indications

• Evaluation of acute medial knee injuries following trauma or sports activity.
• Assessment of chronic medial knee instability or recurrent sprains.
• Preoperative assessment to plan ligament repair or reconstruction.
• Postoperative evaluation to monitor healing and guide rehabilitation.

Contraindications

• Presence of acute fractures in the distal femur, proximal tibia, or patella.
• Severe swelling, hemarthrosis, or pain that prevents proper examination.
• Open wounds, skin infections, or recent surgical incisions over the medial knee.
• Patient inability to tolerate positioning or stress application due to comorbidities.

Technique of the Valgus Stress Test

Patient Positioning

• Place the patient in a supine position on the examination table.
• Ensure the knee is relaxed and muscles are not contracting.
• Perform the test at two positions: full extension (0°) and 30° of knee flexion to assess different fibers of the medial structures.

Examiner Positioning

• Stabilize the distal femur with one hand to prevent unwanted rotation or translation.
• Place the other hand on the distal tibia or ankle to apply a controlled valgus force.
• Ensure the force is applied smoothly without causing pain beyond mild discomfort.

Stepwise Procedure

1. Test at full extension to assess the integrity of the entire MCL complex and joint capsule.
2. Test at 30° knee flexion to isolate the superficial MCL fibers and reduce contribution from the posterior capsule.
3. Compare medial joint opening to the contralateral knee to identify abnormal laxity.

Assessment and Interpretation

• Normal: Minimal medial joint opening with firm end point.
• Abnormal laxity: Increased medial joint opening compared with the opposite knee.
• Grading:
  • Grade I: Mild stretch with no significant joint opening.
  • Grade II: Partial tear with moderate joint opening.
  • Grade III: Complete tear with marked joint opening and absent end point.
• Consider associated injuries such as meniscal tears or anterior cruciate ligament involvement when interpreting results.

Variations and Modifications

Use Under Anesthesia

• Performed when muscle guarding or pain prevents accurate assessment in conscious patients.
• Allows full range of medial joint opening to evaluate true ligament laxity.

Instrumented Valgus Testing Devices

• Specialized devices apply precise valgus force and measure angular displacement.
• Useful for objective assessment, documentation, and research purposes.

Arthroscopic Valgus Testing

• Performed during arthroscopy to directly visualize medial joint opening and ligament integrity.
• Helps guide intraoperative decision making for ligament repair or reconstruction.

Clinical Significance

Diagnosis of MCL Injury

• Valgus stress test helps differentiate between partial and complete MCL tears.
• Correlates closely with MRI findings for confirmation and grading of injury.
• Early detection enables timely management and reduces risk of chronic instability.

Management Implications

• Grade I and II injuries are usually managed conservatively with rest, bracing, and rehabilitation.
• Grade III injuries may require surgical repair or reconstruction, especially in athletes or combined ligament injuries.
• Test results guide rehabilitation protocols and timing of return to sports or physical activity.

Complications and Pitfalls

• False positives can occur due to patient guarding, pain, or poor examiner technique.
• False negatives may result from partial tears with intact fibers or concurrent injuries masking laxity.
• Proper technique, comparison with the contralateral knee, and awareness of patient factors are essential for accurate interpretation.

Imaging Correlation

MRI Evaluation

• Magnetic resonance imaging provides detailed visualization of the medial collateral ligament, meniscus, and joint capsule.
• Detects partial or complete ligament tears, edema, and associated soft tissue injuries.
• Useful in cases where physical examination is inconclusive or when planning surgical intervention.

Ultrasound Assessment

• Dynamic ultrasound can evaluate medial joint opening during applied valgus stress.
• Allows real-time visualization of ligament integrity and surrounding soft tissue structures.
• Portable and cost-effective alternative to MRI, particularly in acute injury settings.

References

1. Martini WZ, et al. Clinical Examination of the Knee. In: Orthopaedic Knowledge Update. 13th ed. Rosemont: AAOS; 2019.
2. Moore KL, Dalley AF, Agur AMR. Clinically Oriented Anatomy. 9th ed. Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer; 2020.
3. Brukner P, Khan K. Clinical Sports Medicine. 5th ed. Sydney: McGraw-Hill; 2019.
4. Rodeo SA, et al. Medial Collateral Ligament Injuries of the Knee. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2021;29(5):e225–e234.
5. Hughston JC, et al. Examination of the Knee. In: Hughston Clinic Sports Medicine Textbook. 2nd ed. New York: Springer; 2018.
6. LaPrade RF, et al. Medial Collateral Ligament and Posteromedial Corner of the Knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(9):2000–2010.
7. Clancy WG, et al. Valgus Stress Test for Medial Knee Ligament Assessment. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1983;177:204–208.
8. Delos D, et al. Imaging of the Medial Knee Ligaments: MRI and Ultrasound. Radiographics. 2020;40(3):748–764.
9. Fetto JF, Marshall JL. Medial Collateral Ligament Injuries: Evaluation and Management. Orthop Clin North Am. 1984;15(1):77–95.
10. Wilson TC, et al. Physical Examination of the Knee: A Review of Special Tests. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2020;13:457–466.