Club foot

Club foot, also called congenital talipes equinovarus, is a complex three-dimensional deformity of the newborn foot. It is defined by a characteristic combination of cavus, forefoot adduction, hindfoot varus, and ankle equinus that, if untreated, impairs function and gait. Early recognition and standardized treatment protocols have transformed outcomes over the past two decades.

This article reviews essential concepts for learners and clinicians, from definitions and scoring systems to contemporary management pathways. It begins with core terminology before moving to epidemiology, pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment.

Introduction

Club foot is one of the most common congenital musculoskeletal conditions encountered in pediatrics and orthopedics. The condition is typically present at birth and can be unilateral or bilateral. Although most cases are idiopathic, some occur in association with neuromuscular or syndromic diagnoses. The functional aim of management is a plantigrade, pain-free, flexible foot that fits into standard footwear and permits normal activity.

Key Features at a Glance

• Multiplanar deformity: classically summarized as CAVE (cavus, adductus, varus, equinus).
• Tissue involvement: bones, joints, ligaments, muscles, tendons, and neurovascular structures.
• Course: amenable to early conservative correction in most infants, with surgery reserved for resistant or relapsed cases.

Clinical Importance

• Potential lifelong impact on gait and participation if inadequately treated.
• High global burden with disparities in access to standardized care.
• Excellent outcomes with timely casting, percutaneous Achilles tenotomy when indicated, and diligent bracing adherence.

Objectives of This Review

• Clarify terminology and classification used in clinical communication and research.
• Outline evidence-based diagnostic and scoring approaches.
• Summarize contemporary non-surgical and surgical management algorithms.

Definition and Terminology

Core Definitions

• Club foot (Congenital Talipes Equinovarus, CTEV): a congenital deformity characterized by hindfoot varus and equinus, forefoot adduction, and midfoot cavus.
• Idiopathic club foot: isolated CTEV without associated neuromuscular or syndromic conditions.
• Non-idiopathic (secondary) club foot: CTEV associated with conditions such as arthrogryposis or spina bifida.

Elements of the Deformity (CAVE)

• Cavus: increased plantar arch due to first-ray plantarflexion.
• Adductus: medial deviation of the forefoot relative to the hindfoot.
• Varus: inversion and medial tilt of the calcaneus and hindfoot.
• Equinus: ankle plantarflexion with limited dorsiflexion at the tibiotalar joint.

Common Terms and Synonyms

• Talipes equinovarus: traditional term synonymous with club foot.
• Postural (positional) club foot: flexible positional deformity due to intrauterine constraint, typically resolves more readily.
• Not club foot: metatarsus adductus, calcaneovalgus foot (distinct entities with different management).

Classification by Clinical Context

Category	Typical Features	Examples	Management Implications
Idiopathic	Otherwise healthy infant, typical CAVE pattern	Isolated unilateral or bilateral CTEV	Excellent response to Ponseti casting and standard bracing
Syndromic	Associated anomalies or genetic syndromes	Arthrogryposis, Larsen syndrome	Stiffer feet, higher relapse risk, more frequent need for surgery
Neurogenic	Underlying neuromuscular pathology	Myelomeningocele, spinal muscular atrophy	Customized protocols, adjunct orthoses, possible staged procedures
Positional (Postural)	Flexible, due to intrauterine positioning	Mild adductus or equinovarus posture	Often responds to stretching and brief casting, lower relapse risk

Epidemiology

Club foot is among the most prevalent congenital musculoskeletal deformities, with significant variability across populations and regions. Understanding its epidemiological profile helps identify at-risk groups, plan screening programs, and allocate resources for effective management.

Incidence and Prevalence

• Global incidence is estimated at 1–2 per 1,000 live births.
• Rates differ between populations, with higher prevalence in some Asian and Polynesian groups and lower prevalence in African populations.
• Bilateral involvement occurs in nearly 50 percent of cases.

Gender Distribution

• Males are more frequently affected than females.
• The male-to-female ratio is typically reported as 2:1.

Ethnic and Geographic Variations

• Studies reveal marked regional differences in prevalence, suggesting genetic and environmental influences.
• Higher prevalence has been documented in regions with limited access to early correction programs, leading to untreated or neglected cases.

Risk Factors

• Family history of club foot, suggesting a genetic predisposition.
• Maternal smoking during pregnancy, associated with increased risk.
• Oligohydramnios and abnormal intrauterine positioning.
• Association with neuromuscular conditions such as spina bifida.

Etiology and Pathogenesis

The cause of club foot is multifactorial, involving genetic, environmental, and developmental contributors. The exact mechanism remains debated, but most evidence points toward a complex interplay between abnormal musculoskeletal development and neuromuscular factors in utero.

Genetic Factors

• Familial clustering suggests heritability, with recurrence risk higher in siblings of affected individuals.
• Several candidate genes and chromosomal loci have been studied, implicating pathways involved in limb development.
• Club foot is also seen as part of syndromic conditions, such as arthrogryposis and Larsen syndrome.

Environmental Factors

• Intrauterine restriction, oligohydramnios, and abnormal fetal positioning may contribute to the development of deformity.
• Maternal health issues, such as smoking or nutritional deficiencies, have been linked to higher incidence.
• Teratogenic exposures may play a role in some cases.

Pathophysiology

• Musculoskeletal abnormalities: Shortened tendons, abnormal ligament structures, and malalignment of the talus, calcaneus, and navicular bones create the fixed deformity.
• Neurological considerations: Evidence suggests mild neuromuscular imbalance, with altered innervation or muscle fiber composition.
• Vascular theories: Hypoperfusion or vascular anomalies during fetal development may impair normal musculoskeletal growth and orientation.

Anatomical and Clinical Features

Club foot is characterized by a distinctive constellation of deformities involving bones, joints, muscles, tendons, and soft tissues. The clinical appearance is usually obvious at birth, although the severity and rigidity can vary. Recognition of the anatomic features is essential for accurate diagnosis and tailored treatment.

Key Anatomical Components

• Equinus deformity: plantarflexion of the ankle joint, with limited dorsiflexion due to shortened Achilles tendon and posterior structures.
• Varus deformity: inversion and medial tilt of the calcaneus, producing a heel that turns inward.
• Adduction of the forefoot: medial displacement of the forefoot relative to the hindfoot, resulting from medial deviation of the navicular and cuboid.
• Cavus deformity: exaggerated medial longitudinal arch, created by plantarflexion of the first metatarsal and tightening of the intrinsic foot musculature.

Clinical Presentation

• The affected foot appears twisted inward and downward at birth, with the sole facing medially or even upward in severe cases.
• Unilateral cases may show asymmetry, with the affected limb appearing smaller in size.
• Bilateral involvement is present in approximately half of the cases.
• Associated anomalies may be found in syndromic or neurogenic cases, such as spinal dysraphism.

Soft Tissue and Muscular Findings

• Shortened and thickened medial soft tissues including tibialis posterior tendon and deltoid ligament.
• Relative hypoplasia of calf muscles, especially in long-standing or untreated cases.
• Reduced bulk and stiffness of the peroneal muscles, contributing to imbalance.

Classification Systems

Several classification systems have been developed to assess the severity of club foot, predict prognosis, and guide treatment planning. These systems consider both clinical presentation and response to correction techniques.

Idiopathic vs Syndromic

• Idiopathic club foot: isolated deformity without additional systemic involvement; generally more responsive to conservative treatment.
• Syndromic club foot: associated with conditions such as arthrogryposis, Down syndrome, or spina bifida; typically stiffer and more resistant to standard correction methods.

Dimeglio Classification

• Evaluates severity based on reducibility of foot position, presence of contractures, and joint stiffness.
• Scores range from mild to very severe, helping clinicians determine the complexity of correction needed.

Pirani Scoring System

• Widely used clinical scoring system, especially in infants undergoing Ponseti treatment.
• Rates six clinical signs including posterior crease, empty heel, rigid equinus, and medial crease.
• Score ranges from 0 (normal) to 6 (most severe), useful for monitoring progress during serial casting.

Other Clinical Grading Methods

• Harrold and Walker classification: based on radiological findings and joint angles.
• Radiographic grading systems: less commonly used in neonates due to limited ossification of tarsal bones.
• Functional outcome-based classifications: assess long-term gait and mobility rather than initial deformity.

Diagnosis

The diagnosis of club foot is primarily clinical, based on characteristic physical findings observed at birth. Imaging is sometimes used to supplement clinical evaluation, particularly in atypical or complex cases. Early diagnosis allows initiation of corrective treatment within the first weeks of life, which is critical for successful outcomes.

Clinical Examination

• Inspection reveals the foot turned inward and downward, often with a deep medial crease.
• Palpation demonstrates stiffness of the hindfoot, limited ankle dorsiflexion, and tightness of the medial soft tissues.
• Assessment of flexibility helps distinguish idiopathic from syndromic or neurogenic cases, which tend to be more rigid.
• Evaluation of limb symmetry and calf circumference is essential, as affected limbs may appear smaller.

Imaging Studies

• X-rays: Can assess tarsal bone alignment, particularly in older infants or relapsed cases. However, limited by incomplete ossification in newborns.
• Ultrasound: Useful in neonates to evaluate cartilaginous structures and foot orientation dynamically.
• Advanced imaging: MRI or CT may be used in research or atypical cases but are not routine for diagnosis.

Differential Diagnosis

• Metatarsus adductus: Medial deviation of forefoot without hindfoot equinus or varus; more flexible than true club foot.
• Postural deformities: Mild positional variations from intrauterine compression, usually resolve spontaneously or with stretching.
• Arthrogryposis: Stiff, rigid feet as part of a generalized congenital joint contracture disorder.
• Vertical talus: Rigid flatfoot deformity with dorsolateral prominence of talar head, sometimes mistaken for severe club foot.

Management

Management of club foot aims to achieve a plantigrade, pain-free, functional foot with long-term mobility. Treatment is guided by severity, classification, and the patient’s age, with most cases responding well to early conservative methods. Surgery is reserved for resistant or relapsed deformities.

Non-Surgical Management

• Ponseti method: Standard of care worldwide. Involves gentle weekly manipulations, serial casting, percutaneous Achilles tenotomy when necessary, followed by long-term bracing to prevent relapse.
• French functional method: Daily physiotherapy with stretching, taping, and splinting. Requires skilled therapists and parental compliance.
• Bracing and orthotics: Post-correction maintenance with foot abduction braces is crucial to prevent relapse.
• Physiotherapy approaches: Targeted stretching, strengthening, and parental education enhance long-term outcomes.

Surgical Management

• Indications: Reserved for cases unresponsive to conservative methods or for recurrent deformities after initial correction.
• Posterior medial release: Involves lengthening or release of tight tendons and capsules, particularly Achilles tendon and posterior tibial tendon.
• Achilles tendon lengthening: Often performed as a percutaneous tenotomy in infants or open procedure in older children.
• External fixation techniques: Ilizarov or hexapod fixators may be used in complex relapsed or rigid deformities for gradual correction.

Complications

Despite advances in treatment, complications may arise due to severity of deformity, inadequate correction, poor compliance with bracing, or surgical interventions. Recognizing potential complications allows early intervention to minimize long-term disability.

• Residual deformity: Incomplete correction may persist, often involving residual equinus or varus.
• Relapse after treatment: Common in idiopathic cases if bracing protocols are not followed, often requiring repeat casting or surgical procedures.
• Overcorrection: Excessive correction can result in calcaneovalgus or rocker-bottom deformity, impairing function.
• Stiffness and pain: More frequent after extensive surgical release, leading to reduced range of motion and discomfort during ambulation.
• Skin complications: Pressure sores and blisters may develop during casting or bracing if not monitored properly.

Prognosis

The long-term outlook for patients with club foot has improved dramatically with modern treatment protocols. Prognosis depends on timing of intervention, adherence to bracing, and whether the condition is idiopathic or associated with syndromic or neuromuscular disorders.

Functional Outcomes

• Most children treated with the Ponseti method achieve a plantigrade, pain-free, and functional foot.
• Children are usually able to participate in normal physical activities, including sports.
• Untreated or inadequately managed cases often result in significant disability and gait abnormalities.

Long-term Gait Analysis

• Studies show near-normal gait patterns in corrected idiopathic cases, with minimal limitations in dorsiflexion or inversion strength.
• Some patients may have mild calf atrophy or leg-length discrepancy, but these rarely affect daily function.
• Syndromic or neurogenic club foot cases often show persistent abnormalities, necessitating orthotic support or repeated interventions.

Impact on Quality of Life

• Early correction and adherence to follow-up ensure good cosmetic and functional results, reducing psychosocial burden.
• Children treated successfully integrate into normal schooling and social activities without restrictions.
• Neglected club foot remains a major cause of lifelong disability in regions lacking access to proper care.

Prevention and Screening

Although not all cases of club foot can be prevented due to strong genetic and developmental factors, certain measures can aid in early detection and intervention. Screening programs and prenatal diagnosis play an important role in reducing the burden of untreated or neglected cases.

Antenatal Detection by Ultrasound

• Club foot can often be identified on routine second-trimester ultrasound, typically after 18–20 weeks of gestation.
• Bilateral involvement is more reliably detected than unilateral cases.
• Prenatal detection allows counseling of parents and planning for postnatal treatment.

Genetic Counseling

• Families with a history of club foot may benefit from genetic counseling to understand recurrence risk.
• While no single gene is responsible, patterns of inheritance suggest multifactorial influence.
• Parents can be advised on the importance of early follow-up after birth if risk factors are present.

Public Health Implications

• Education of healthcare workers and parents about the importance of early recognition and referral is crucial.
• Community-based screening programs improve timely initiation of Ponseti casting, particularly in resource-limited settings.
• Awareness campaigns help prevent neglect and reduce stigma associated with visible deformities.

Recent Advances and Research

Research into the causes and treatment of club foot continues to evolve, with emphasis on refining conservative techniques, exploring genetic contributions, and applying new technologies for personalized care.

Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine Approaches

• Experimental studies are exploring stem cell therapy to enhance tendon and ligament healing in relapsed cases.
• Regenerative medicine may offer new solutions for muscle imbalance and tissue scarring seen in complex cases.

Genetic Studies

• Genome-wide association studies have identified candidate loci linked to limb development pathways.
• Improved understanding of gene-environment interactions may lead to targeted prevention strategies in the future.

Advances in Imaging and 3D Modeling

• Three-dimensional ultrasound and MRI provide better insights into fetal musculoskeletal development.
• 3D printing technology is being applied to create customized orthoses and teaching models.
• Computer-assisted gait analysis is increasingly used to evaluate long-term functional outcomes after correction.

References

1. Dobbs MB, Gurnett CA. Update on clubfoot: etiology and treatment. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009;467(5):1146-1153.
2. Ponseti IV. Congenital clubfoot: fundamentals of treatment. Oxford University Press; 1996.
3. Dimeglio A, Bensahel H, Souchet P, Mazeau P, Bonnet F. Classification of clubfoot. J Pediatr Orthop B. 1995;4(2):129-136.
4. Pirani S, Outerbridge HK, Moran M, Sawatzky B. A method of evaluating the virgin clubfoot with substantial interobserver reliability. Presented at the 21st SICOT Congress; 1993.
5. Morcuende JA, Dolan LA, Dietz FR, Ponseti IV. Radical reduction in the rate of extensive corrective surgery for clubfoot using the Ponseti method. Pediatrics. 2004;113(2):376-380.
6. Shabtai L, Specht SC, Herzenberg JE. Worldwide spread of the Ponseti method for clubfoot. World J Orthop. 2014;5(5):585-590.
7. Khan SA, Kumar A. Clubfoot: etiology and management. Indian J Orthop. 2012;46(2):144-153.
8. Turco VJ. Resistant congenital clubfoot: one-stage posteromedial release with internal fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61(6A):805-814.
9. Mazzocca AD, Thomson JD. Pediatric foot disorders. In: Canale ST, Beaty JH, editors. Campbell’s operative orthopaedics. 13th ed. Elsevier; 2017. p. 1359-1386.
10. Gibbons PJ, Gray K. Update on clubfoot. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2013;25(1):72-76.